ABCD Review Workspace
Replay the trade, decide what it proves, write the lesson, and move back into the review queue. Execution-only for Long trade / 2026-05-01 / market_open
Trade MenuPage sectionsTap to jump around this page.
Trade review hub
What happened, what to review, and what to write down
ABCD Long trade trade from 2026-05-01. Gross P/L is -400.00; lifecycle is flat. This is re-entry 1 inside the re-entry is still open story.
Trade Review Flow
Replay, decide, write, then continue
This page is the workbench for one saved trade. Replay the buys and sells first, use chart evidence only when it is saved, then write one practical lesson before moving to the next trade.
1. Replay
See the entry, adds, reductions, and exit
Start here so the note is based on what the trader actually did.
Replay executions
2. Decide
Decide what this trade can prove
Check ticker, session, chart, and volume handoffs only when the saved evidence exists.
Use context
3. Write
Record one fix or one strength to repeat
Save the note and checklist so coach and progress know the work is done.
Write lesson
4. Continue
Move to the next saved review
Return to the queue after this review instead of wandering through unrelated stats.
Next trade
Session Story
2026-05-01 / Green-to-red session
The session reached +3.50 before finishing -235.70.
Find the point where the day changed and decide what rule would have stopped the next weaker attempt.
Session P/L
-235.70
9 round trips
Symbols Traded
2
Different tickers in this session
Strengths To Repeat
0
0 profit-protection strengths
Repeated Ticker Stories
2
Same-symbol stories to check
Open Or Swing Reviews
1
Trades needing hold-plan review
The session went from green to red
The session reached +3.50 before finishing -235.70.
Find the trade or re-entry that changed the day and write what should have stopped the next attempt.
Saved import data
One ticker had multiple attempts
ABCD had 7 round trips for -201.70.
Separate fresh setups from attempts to remake the same move.
Saved import data
High trade count to review
9 round trips across 2 symbols were saved for this session.
Check whether each trade had its own plan or whether activity increased after the first loss.
Execution replay
Open or extended-hold exposure needs separate review
1 ticker story included an open re-entry, extended same-day hold, or next-session hold.
Review hold plan, size, and invalidation separately from the original intraday idea.
Execution replay
What Happened
-400.00
ABCD / market_open
What To Review
Execution review
Execution-only review
What To Write Down
57% complete
Use the checklist's next item.
What Is Unavailable
Chart data
Use execution evidence now.
What happened
-400.00 / 5 executions
Start with the execution replay before writing the lesson.
Behavior to name
What needs to happen before this open re-entry can be reviewed as complete?
Name the main risk or question in plain trader language.
Fix first
Compare the later entry against the first winning push and check whether the setup was still fresh.
Write one next-session rule before opening supporting details.
Evidence
Repeated execution-only mistakes can turn into personal rules and review drills.
Use saved execution, chart status, and ticker-story evidence only when available.
Write The Review Note
Write one short lesson while the replay is still in front of you: what happened, what behavior mattered, and what you will fix first.
What happened?
What behavior mattered?
What is the fix-first rule?
2026-05-02T20:00:00.000Z
Check the trigger for each add before the first reduction.
Save Review Progress
Mark the steps you have actually reviewed. These choices survive reloads.
Entry Review
Complete
No entry-specific risk is currently linked.
Add Review
attention
3 add(s), 3 add(s) after adverse movement.
Exit Review
Complete
1 reduction(s) found.
Sizing Review
Complete
Sizing did not trigger a negative driver.
Risk Review
attention
Review adds that need chart data
Lesson Review
Complete
Check the trigger for each add before the first reduction.
Rule Review
attention
Require Repair Before Adding Size
After Saving This Review
Turn the trade into progress follow-through.
A saved note is the lesson. Completed checklist items are what move this from imported history into reviewed work the coach can use.
Ticker Story
ABCD had 7 round trips on 2026-05-01
The trader got flat, re-entered the ticker, and the imported executions do not show a completed exit yet.
Open intraday re-entry
The trader re-entered after getting flat, but the later round trip is still open in the imported executions.
Review only the completed execution evidence now. Wait for the position to close before treating the full re-entry story as complete.
Review Question
What needs to happen before this open re-entry can be reviewed as complete?
Fix first: Compare the later entry against the first winning push and check whether the setup was still fresh.
-201.70
Story P/L
The re-entry is not complete yet
The imported executions show a later re-entry, but they do not show the position returning to flat.
Review the completed trade first and wait for a closing execution before judging the full re-entry.
Execution replay
Later trading gave back earlier profit
The ticker story reached +3.50 before giving back 205.20.
Compare the later entry against the first winning push and check whether the setup was still fresh.
Saved import data
Time between exit and re-entry
The first re-entry came -0 minutes after the prior flat exit.
Review whether the re-entry had a fresh reason or was an attempt to remake the same move.
Execution replay
The re-entry had more executions
Trade 2 used 5 executions versus 4 in the first round trip.
Check whether the added executions were planned trade management or reactive chopping.
Execution replay
The weakest push was a re-entry
Trade 2 was the weakest round trip at -400.00.
Start review on that re-entry and compare its entry timing, exit plan, and size to the first push.
Saved import data
Round Trips
7
6 flat / 1 open
Best Push
+110.40
Trade 3
Weakest Push
-400.00
Trade 2
Giveback
-205.20
Profit reduced after the best cumulative point.
First pushhour n/a / 4 executions / 9:30 AM ETChart data still missing+3.50Currenthour n/a / 5 executions / 9:30 AM ETChart data still missing-400.00Re-entry 2hour n/a / 3 executions / 9:31 AM ETChart data still missing+110.40Re-entry 3hour n/a / 3 executions / 9:33 AM ETChart data still missing+66.00Re-entry 4hour n/a / 2 executions / 9:35 AM ETChart data still missing+50.00Re-entry 5hour n/a / 2 executions / 11:10 AM ETChart data still missing-42.00Re-entry 6hour n/a / 2 executions / 2:45 PM ETChart data still missing+10.40
What This Review Can Use
Execution-only review
No saved chart evidence is attached yet, so this page is limited to execution evidence.
Next: Review entries, adds, reductions, exits, timing, and P/L evidence.
Execution-only
Gross P/L
-400.00
Executions
5
Max Position
400
Lifecycle
Flat
Session Time
Market session and entry-hour analytics are classified in Eastern Time.
09:00-09:59 ET
Entry Session
market_open
Entry Hour
09:00-09:59 ET
Held Through
market_open
Exposure Segments
2
09:00-09:59 ETmarket_open2026-05-01T13:30:00.000Z to 2026-05-01T14:00:00.000Z30.0m
10:00-10:59 ETmarket_open2026-05-01T14:00:00.000Z to 2026-05-01T14:05:00.000Z5.0m
Trade Review Checklist
Review whether each add had repair evidence or only increased exposure.
57%
Entry Reviewcomplete
No entry-specific risk is currently linked.
Check whether the first execution followed the plan.
Add Reviewattention
3 add(s), 3 add(s) after adverse movement.
Review whether each add had repair evidence or only increased exposure.
Exit Reviewcomplete
1 reduction(s) found.
Check whether the exit reduced risk at the right moment.
Sizing Reviewcomplete
Sizing did not trigger a negative driver.
Compare initial size, max size, and final size.
Risk Reviewattention
Review adds that need chart data
Write the exact risk moment before judging the trade.
Lesson Reviewcomplete
Check the trigger for each add before the first reduction.
Capture one sentence about what to repeat or avoid.
Rule Reviewattention
Require Repair Before Adding Size
Review the linked draft rule before saving later.
Trade Replay
Follow the execution sequence before writing the review. ABCD finished as a gross loser with an execution quality score of 54/100.
54/100
execution quality
Max position
400
Biggest share exposure in this round trip.
Final position
0
This round trip closed back to flat.
Realized P/L path
-400.00
Execution-derived realized P/L is visible after reductions or exits. Final visible P/L is -400.00.
Execution Price Path
Saved fills only. Candle movement and market context can be layered in after chart data is attached.
5 fills
1Entry
9:30 AM ET100 shares at $10.00
Position 0 to 100
2Add
9:32 AM ET100 shares at $9.5000
Position 100 to 200
3Add
9:34 AM ET100 shares at $9.0000
Position 200 to 300
4Add
9:36 AM ET100 shares at $8.5000
Position 300 to 400
5Exit to flat
10:05 AM ET400 shares at $8.2500
Position 400 to 0
EntryAddReduceExit
1. Entry9:30 AM ET
100 shares at $10.00
Initial entry
Position after execution0 -> 100
Review adds that need chart dataAdded several times before reducing size
Execution-derived P/L
P/L not realized yet
No reduction or exit has realized P/L here.
2. Add9:32 AM ET
100 shares at $9.5000
Added size
Position after execution100 -> 200
Review adds that need chart dataAdded several times before reducing size
Execution-derived P/L
P/L not realized yet
No reduction or exit has realized P/L here.
3. Add9:34 AM ET
100 shares at $9.0000
Added size
Position after execution200 -> 300
Review adds that need chart dataAdded several times before reducing size
Execution-derived P/L
P/L not realized yet
No reduction or exit has realized P/L here.
4. Add9:36 AM ET
100 shares at $8.5000
Added size
Position after execution300 -> 400
Review adds that need chart dataAdded several times before reducing size
Execution-derived P/L
P/L not realized yet
No reduction or exit has realized P/L here.
5. Exit to flat10:05 AM ET
400 shares at $8.2500
Closed to flat
Position after execution400 -> 0
Closed the trade cleanlyConsistent position sizing
Execution-derived P/L
-400.00
Realized after this execution.
Risks And Strengths
Risks
Review adds that need chart data
Inspect each add and decide whether it had repair evidence or only increased exposure.
Added several times before reducing size
The position kept getting larger before the trade sold or reduced a meaningful amount.
Built too much size in a losing trade
The position became much larger while the trade later finished as a gross loser.
Many adds before one large exit
The trade built size through several adds and then relied on one large exit sequence.
Reduced after price was against the entry
At least one reduction happened at a price worse than the prior average entry.
Strengths
Closed the trade cleanly
The execution sequence includes a clear final exit that returned the position to flat.
Consistent position sizing
Entry-side execution sizes stayed within a tighter range, making the trade easier to review.
Execution Score Detail
Entry Discipline82/100
Entry discipline looks for unusually tight execution timing and clean single-entry evidence.
Add Discipline12/100
Add discipline rewards controlled scaling and flags adds made after price moved against the position.
Exit Discipline66/100
Exit discipline looks for clean full exits, structured partial exits, shares left open, and weak first reductions.
Risk Control24/100
Risk control focuses on adds after price moved against the position, shares left open, and aggressive size expansion.
Sizing Consistency86/100
Sizing consistency penalizes erratic share-size changes and unusually large position expansion.
Overall Quality54/100
Overall quality averages execution-only entry, add, exit, risk, and sizing dimensions.
Execution Decision Notes
Initial entryinitial_entry
BUY 100 at 10; position moved to 100.
Added sizeadd
BUY 100 at 9.5; position moved to 200.
Review adds that need chart data / Added several times before reducing size
Added sizeadd
BUY 100 at 9; position moved to 300.
Review adds that need chart data / Added several times before reducing size
Added sizeadd
BUY 100 at 8.5; position moved to 400.
Review adds that need chart data / Added several times before reducing size
Full exitfull_exit
SELL 400 at 8.25; position moved to 0.
Closed the trade cleanly / Consistent position sizing
More evidence, comparisons, and writing prompts
Score Explanation
ABCD graded mixed; use the replay to review add discipline first.54/100
Add Discipline12/100
Add discipline rewards controlled scaling and flags adds made after price moved against the position.
Risk Control24/100
Risk control focuses on adds after price moved against the position, shares left open, and aggressive size expansion.
Entry Discipline82/100
Entry discipline looks for unusually tight execution timing and clean single-entry evidence.
Sizing Consistency86/100
Sizing consistency penalizes erratic share-size changes and unusually large position expansion.
Exit Discipline66/100
Exit discipline looks for clean full exits, structured partial exits, shares left open, and weak first reductions.
Open the saved trade replay and inspect add discipline.
Supporting Evidence
Repeated risky ABCD tradesSaved review evidence
Detected from repeated same-symbol saved trades with risk labels or losing outcomes.
Compare the same-symbol replays and decide whether a ticker cooldown rule would help.
Added several times before reducing sizeSaved review evidence
Detected from the execution sequence: several adds happened before the first meaningful reduction.
Mark where size had to stop increasing unless the chart had clearly repaired.
Built too much size in a losing tradeSaved review evidence
Detected from gross losing outcome plus size expansion or overbuilt-position risk evidence.
Define a maximum add count or maximum size for trades that have not started working.
Many adds before one large exitSaved review evidence
Detected from several add executions followed by a heavy exit sequence.
Plan an earlier risk reduction so the trade does not depend on one final exit.
ABCD quality: 54/100Saved review evidence
ABCD graded mixed; use the replay to review add discipline first.
Open the saved trade replay and inspect add discipline.
Behavior Timeline
Repeated risky ABCD trades#1
Detected from repeated same-symbol saved trades with risk labels or losing outcomes. Likely review point: Initial entry.
high confidence / initial_entry
Added several times before reducing size#2
Detected from the execution sequence: several adds happened before the first meaningful reduction. Likely review point: Added size.
medium confidence / add
Built too much size in a losing trade#2
Detected from gross losing outcome plus size expansion or overbuilt-position risk evidence. Likely review point: Added size.
medium confidence / add
Review adds that need chart data#2
Detected from adverse-price add evidence in the saved execution summary. Likely review point: Added size.
medium confidence / add
Review adds that need chart data#2
Detected from saved execution facts that count adds after adverse movement. Likely review point: Added size.
medium confidence / add
Many adds before one large exit#5
Detected from several add executions followed by a heavy exit sequence. Likely review point: Full exit.
medium confidence / full_exit
Similar Trades
Use these as comparison examples after this trade has one clear lesson.
Journal Prompts
Strength review
What did you do before closed the trade cleanly that could be repeated?